Every person naturally gravitates to others who look, sound, smell, and seem like their self. All humans are naturally bonded in families. And, we are tribal by nature. So, the identity politics comes naturally in a democratic republic. Consequently, a key issue is which identity matters the most?
Are you a White, Christian American?
Or, an Asian-American Christian?
Or, an Afro-American?
Or, a Tejano, American Woman?
Or, how about an old, Southern Conservative?
Maybe a Hetero-normative, young Mom?
What is the defining noun for your identity?
Understanding, of course, that to a foreigner you may be an American, to an American you may be a Southerner, to a Southerner you may be a Virginian, to a Virginian you may be a Tidewater or Peninsula person, to a Tidewater neighbor you may be a Poquoson resident, to a Poquoson person you may be a Bull Islander or a Move In and to a Bull Islander you may be a Muddy Toe or and Up Roader.
The audience you address determines which identity you use.
So, what is your most defining noun? The one to which all other adjectives apply?
If it’s race, class, or gender(s), you are a Cultural Marxist. Whether you acknowledge it or not. You are self-defining in their twisted language for their tangled purposes.
If it’s any class of oppressed vs. oppressor groups, you are a Cultural Marxist. Even if you don’t know what Intersectionality is, you are buying into it.
The Left makes identity politics their idol. Human Secularist Totalitarianism is their ideology and true religion. Regardless of whatever faith they claim.
Americans divided by the social construct of “race”, their ethnicities or countries of origin, native language other than English, class or privilege, and gender are split along harmful lines.
That was true in 1776 and worsens for potential harm every year since. Doing so makes America approach the precipice of Civil War – along different, more dangerous lines than regional sub-cultures.
Racial identity politics cripple Blacks more than help themselves to Government cheese. Black identity politics haven’t uplifted Black ghettoes in cities. Generations on the Government plantation made too many modern slaves go feral following the Federal and State Welfare’s destruction of the nuclear family. There’s a new class of Black plantation owners and overseers in government and government-funded non-profit jobs.
Racial and ethnic identity politics for other minorities divide our Nation further along the most meaningless lines. Racial and ethnic identity is the easy, natural, human appeal to tribalism.
Tribalism is barbarism. America as a Nation-State subsumed tribalism and regional identity into a consensus culture and worldview.
Politicians never stopped exploited identity politics. It’s easy and cheaper to win on emotions than intellect and good governance. That doesn’t make identity politics right. Or good.
The better way for our pluralistic America is to change identity politics into idea politics. (Noted: The “Idea” for Cultural Marxism is their identity). So, the real political ideas, not the CRT immutable characteristics established at birth, of the Left should compete with the ideas of Conservatives.
That melts the “diversity” of tribal identities into a team based on ideas. And, as long as the better ideas – which are the Conservative ones – win, it’s much better for all Americans.
Finally, when your ideas are purposeful and ascendant you have a purpose. Like, family, faith, and freedom. Western Civilization. Christianity and Judaism.
For the record, my definitive noun in my self-identity is “Christian”.
I am an American Christian.
Read James Atticus Bowden at https://jatticus.wordpress.com/ and https://substack.com/@jamesatticusbowden and https://x.com/jatticusbowden
If you enjoyed this article, then please REPOST or SHARE with others; encourage them to follow AFNN. If you’d like to become a citizen contributor for AFNN, contact us at managingeditor@afnn.us Help keep us ad-free by donating here.
Substack: American Free News Network Substack
Truth Social: @AFNN_USA
Facebook: https://m.facebook.com/afnnusa
Telegram: https://t.me/joinchat/2_-GAzcXmIRjODNh
Twitter: https://twitter.com/AfnnUsa
GETTR: https://gettr.com/user/AFNN_USA
CloutHub: @AFNN_USA