Are We Headed Toward a Second Mexican-American War? A Military Strategic Assessment

I. Introduction

In 1846, the United States invaded Mexico.

The war was controversial then, and remains deeply significant now—not just because it added vast territory to the U.S., but because it revealed core truths about how political ideology, nationalism, and instability can lead to major conflict. Nearly 180 years later, there are eerie similarities echoing across the southern border—this time in the form of cartel violence, cultural unrest, and ideological flashpoints erupting in American cities.

This isn’t 1846. But what’s happening today may be laying the groundwork for a new kind of war with Mexico—one not of uniforms and flags, but of shadow networks, failed borders, and social fracture.

II. Historical Overview: The First Mexican-American War (1846–1848)

The Mexican-American War was triggered by a border dispute after the U.S. annexed Texas in 1845. Mexico had never accepted Texan independence, and certainly not its inclusion into the United States. The U.S. insisted the border was the Rio Grande; Mexico claimed it was the Nueces River, further north.

When President James K. Polk sent U.S. troops into the disputed zone, Mexican forces attacked. Polk used this as a pretext for war, claiming that “American blood has been shed on American soil.”

But the truth was more complex. Polk had already offered to buy California and New Mexico from Mexico. Mexico refused. And many Americans—especially Northerners like Abraham Lincoln—suspected the war was a smokescreen to expand slave territory under the guise of Manifest Destiny.

The war lasted two years and resulted in the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, where Mexico ceded over half its territory, including present-day California, Arizona, New Mexico, Utah, Nevada, and parts of several other states.

While it was a stunning geopolitical victory for the U.S., it left deep scars in Mexico—humiliation, loss, and national resentment that never fully healed.

III. Mexico Today: A Nation Under Siege

Mexico in the 21st century is not under threat from American armies—but from within.

Cartels have evolved from smuggling operations into full-fledged insurgencies. They control entire regions, bribe or kill elected officials, assassinate journalists, and maintain their own intelligence, logistics, and weapons networks. In some states like Michoacán, Jalisco, or Tamaulipas, the Mexican state has essentially lost control.

These groups are not merely criminals—they are non-state actors engaging in narco-terrorism. They maintain relationships with Chinese fentanyl suppliers, U.S.-based gangs, and arms smugglers. And they operate across the U.S. border with impunity.

IV. U.S. Cities as Cultural Flashpoints

Simultaneously, unrest is rising inside the U.S.—particularly in cities like Los Angeles, where massive protests have included the waving of Mexican flags, clashes with law enforcement, and open advocacy for the idea of “Aztlán”—a radical ideology that claims the American Southwest should be returned to Mexico.

This is not a widely held belief among Mexican-Americans, the vast majority of whom are peaceful, law-abiding, and patriotic. But in times of political polarization, radical voices often become disproportionately influential. As riots and protests escalate, the question arises: How does a sovereign nation respond when foreign ideology, crime, and national symbols are weaponized against it—on its own soil?

V. Are We Headed Toward a Second War?

A conventional war between the U.S. and Mexico is unlikely. The Mexican military would be no match, and the international consequences would be enormous. But a non-conventional conflict is not just possible—it’s arguably already underway.

Hybrid warfare is defined by blurred lines between military, criminal, political, and cultural forces. The current state of U.S.-Mexico relations fits this model:

• Cartels operate across borders with military-grade weapons.

• Mass migration is destabilizing infrastructure and security in border states.

• U.S. cities are becoming centers of unrest tied to foreign political grievances.

• National identity is eroding in favor of transnational ideologies.

In this sense, we are already in a second Mexican-American crisis.

VI. Military Strategic Assessment

Most Likely Course of Action (MLCOA):

• Cartel violence increases, but remains below the threshold that forces direct military confrontation.

• Border security tightens incrementally, but political paralysis prevents effective nationwide policy.

• Cultural flashpoints continue to simmer—especially in election years—but are managed by local law enforcement.

• Mexico continues to oscillate between weak federal control and cartel dominance.

Most Dangerous Course of Action (MDCOA):

• Cartel violence expands into large-scale attacks on U.S. soil (e.g., mass casualty events, assassinations, infrastructure sabotage).

• Mexican government collapses in key provinces, leading to a failed-state scenario along the U.S. border.

• Radical political factions in the U.S. exploit cultural tensions, leading to riots, insurrections, and targeted violence against federal agencies.

• U.S. military is deployed to the border or even across it, either covertly or through public authorization, resulting in international backlash and possible conflict spillover.

VII. Conclusion

The First Mexican-American War was a conflict of ambition, ideology, and weakness. The crisis unfolding today is shaped by similar dynamics—but with different weapons. Cartels instead of armies. Social media instead of cavalry. Fentanyl instead of muskets.

Whether this crisis escalates into an outright confrontation will depend not just on policy, but on whether the U.S. still has the will—and unity—to act like a sovereign nation.

History doesn’t always repeat, but in America, it often reloads.

If you enjoyed this article, then please REPOST or SHARE with others; encourage them to follow AFNN. If you’d like to become a citizen contributor for AFNN, contact us at managingeditor@afnn.us Help keep us ad-free by donating here.

Substack: American Free News Network Substack
Truth Social:  https://truthsocial.com/@AFNN_USA
Facebook: https://m.facebook.com/afnnusa
Telegram: https://t.me/joinchat/2_-GAzcXmIRjODNh
Twitter: https://twitter.com/AfnnUsa
GETTR: https://gettr.com/user/AFNN_USA
CloutHub: @AFNN_USA

Leave a Comment